Skip to main content

Mistakes Are What You Make of Them.

As soon as I kinked my second tube I knew I would need more to get two good wingtip bows, so I placed an order for three 7' long pieces of tubing. I only needed about 6' to make one bow, but there is almost no leverage for the last of the bend unless you add some excess. I bought three in case I messed another one up beyond saving. Happily, Wicks Aircraft still had the tubing I needed for $1.05 a foot. About $50 and two days later I had my tubing and borrowed a conduit bender from work.

I took a scrap from my kinked tubing and tried bending it with the conduit bender; INSTANT KINK.
Ooookay... now what?
 I read some more from Tony Bingelis' Sportplane Construction Techniques, quoted below.
"Thin wall tubing is more difficult to bend successfully because it is very quick to flatten and buckle"
The wingtip tubing is .028" wall; the tubing used in the rest of the fuselage is .035" wall or greater.
"The larger the diameter of the tubing, the greater its excess length should be. Allow and extra 12" on each end for tubing up to 3/4" in diameter."
"Before you attempt to bend any large diameter tube (3/4" or larger) you should fill it with densely packed sand."
Ta-da. I never packed my tubing with sand before trying a bend. I'd heard of it being done, but didn't think it would be necessary for something like this. Clearly I was wrong.

 Armed with this new information I embarked on. I'll let "Uncle Tony" describe the process.

"Plug the bottom end of the tube with a wood plug and pour in the sand. Tap the bottom end of the tube repeatedly against a solid surface (concrete floor). After the tube is full of sand, the continued tapping will cause it to settle and pack more densely. Add additional sand. After the sand shows no further sign of settling, drive a wood plug into the top end of the tube, making sure it bottoms solidly against the sand. Your tube is now ready for bending. The risk of a flattened bend will be considerably reduced."

  I tried my first sand-packed tube bend with scrap tubing in the conduit bender. It kinked, but not as badly. So, I cut off the kinked bit, repacked the tubing, and tried again with the plywood bender I had made before. Success! I proceeded to bend up the scrap piece, matching my wingtip pattern as I went to get a feel for the process. I almost had enough tubing for a usable part, but not quite.
  With one attempt mostly successful, I went on to bend two of my three new tubes into wingtip bows. Each successive bend went faster and smoother than the last.
 The one bit of information I would like to add to Tony's instructions: If you have a tight bend near an end, make that at what was the bottom end when you were packing sand. The bottom end has the most densely packed sand because of the weight of the sand packing in above it. 
I had some slight wrinkling at the inside of the tightest bend, but not enough to be concerned with. Below is a picture of the too-short test piece and the two good bows. There is extra material at each end that will need to be cut off and trimmed to fit the wing's leading and trailing edge. The test piece will be very helpful in practicing these cuts as well.
 It turns out those "wasted" hours making a plywood bending form weren't a waste after all.

Total Time: 214.8 hrs.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Fittings. How fitting.

  Not much has happened on the Ace this year. The winter was long and spring has been very cold, so I spent a long time waiting for the garage to warm up. Now that there's a little heat down there I've been making some headway on the next step of my wing build: fittings. I copied the parts off the plans into CAD and then printed them onto cardstock to use as patterns when laying fittings out on the steel stock.    First I tackled the brackets that will hold the pulleys for the aileron cables. I have a lot of extra material in case I had to remake these. The next step was to bend up my fittings. There is one fitting that mounts to the forward side of the strut which gets bent to a 90° angle. The fitting which mounts to the aft side of the spar gets bent at about an 85° angle. I forget the exact number, but don't feel like looking it up at the moment. Next I cut out the aileron control horns. My Harbor Freight porta-band chucked into my vice works well for cutting thes

10 months in under 10 minutes.

I don't feel like going into depth on every little aspect of work I've done over the last 10 months, so I'll hit the highlights and if anyone has questions, feel free to comment and I'll elaborate.  As the year started the garage was cold. With a propane heater it would get warm enough to work for a few hours, but because 4130 steel is an air-tempered alloy, it needs to be sufficiently warm out for welding. Long story short; I can't weld, so I make parts. I plugged away making little bits so I can use them when it comes time to build a new assembly. The landing gear legs and spring struts have metal straps to reinforce the bushings in the ends. I knocked these out in a couple days after work. Likewise, the tabs that will become door hinges and the fittings for the tailwheel were cut, drilled, and deburred. As it warmed up and I got an order of laser-cut parts the aileron control arm and pulley brackets were welded to the torque tube for the control stick.  I also cu

3-D and waiting.

On January 18th I posted my last blog update; both fuselage sides were tack welded. That was seven months ago now. I should update more regularly. Okay, self-flagellation over, let's get to the content! Once both fuselage sides were tack welded, I pulled all the jig blocks off the table, elected not to repaint again, and just laid out the stations for the top view of the fuselage. We lay out the top view because the top of the fuselage is flat which makes it a lot easier to jig things up if you lay out the fuselage upside-down. With the top view lofted out on the table I could start adding in jig blocks starting in the cockpit area where the sides are parallel. A stick and some clamps help hold the sides parallel for this photo op.  Now may be a good time to mention, if I haven't already, that I am widening this fuselage from stock. The original Jr Ace (Model E) was 33-1/8" between tubing centerlines at the widest point. This makes for a pretty cramped space when two peopl